The Debate: Should Every High School Graduate Go to College?

For years, the conventional wisdom has been that high school graduates should prioritize a college education to secure a prosperous future. This perspective often hinges on the belief that a college degree is the only pathway to a well-paying job. However, the truth is more complex.

Recently, a nephew of mine who never attended college but instead chose to go to a trade school has caught everyone’s attention. He now makes an impressive $100,000 a year as an alarm system installer and repair technician. This scenario presents a significant counterclaim to the traditional view.

A Skilled Trade as a Viable Alternative

The counterclaim poses a strong argument in favor of trade schools and the skilled trades. For many high school graduates, the choice between college and alternative pathways such as trade school or community college can be a matter of practicality and personal interest. The skilled trades, including fields like electrical work, plumbing, and alarm system installation, offer immediate, high-paying jobs and often a path to career advancement and entrepreneurship.

High Demand in Skilled Trades

Despite the popular perception, there is a significant need for skilled workers. In fact, trade school graduates can contribute to a wide variety of services that do not require advanced degrees. From installing alarm systems to servicing electricity, skilled trades people play a crucial role in the functioning of our society. These professions are critical and often underestimated.

Real-Life Examples

Consider the case of my plumber, who makes $100,000 a year. This salary is not only high but also comes with weekends off and an excellent benefits package. Such examples challenge the notion that a college degree is the only route to financial success. Additionally, baby boomers in the skilled trades are retiring, leaving behind a dearth of experienced workers in fields such as plumbing, electrical work, and heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC).

For high school graduates, the path to becoming a plumber, electrician, or other skilled trades often starts with an apprenticeship. These apprenticeships come with a starting wage, typically around $15 per hour, and provide hands-on training and mentorship. Once qualified, individuals can earn competitive salaries like my plumber’s.

Earn while Learning

Even a community college degree, such as an associate of applied science degree, can lead to well-paying jobs. Many states offer free tuition programs for these associate degrees, making them a more affordable option than a four-year degree. These programs focus on specific professional skills, providing students with the necessary qualifications to enter the workforce immediately after graduation.

The Reality of the Job Market

While college can open up a wide range of career opportunities, it is not the only path to a successful career. In fact, there are numerous well-paying jobs that do not require a traditional four-year college degree. The reality is that many high school graduates who opt for trade school or community college still achieve excellent career outcomes.

Case Study: My Nephew at the University

My nephew, who attended trade school instead of college, now works at the university earning $100,000 a year with weekends off and a comprehensive benefits package. This case illustrates that even those who choose an alternative route can still achieve impressive financial success and job satisfaction.

Conclusion: The Shift in Job Demand

It is becoming increasingly clear that the job market is shifting away from the traditional college-first model. While college remains a valuable option for many students, there are numerous pathways to success, including trade school, community college, and vocational training. Trade school and the skilled trades offer immediate, high-paying jobs and a path to career growth and entrepreneurship, making them a compelling alternative for many high school graduates.

In the end, the decision to pursue college or an alternative pathway should be based on individual interests, skills, and career aspirations. The skilled trades offer a viable and often lucrative option for those who may not be interested in a four-year college degree.